Saturday, October 24, 2026

Daniel Bell, The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism (1976 [1996])

This book was rather disappointing. I came to it with high hopes. Paul Lachelier, with whom I'm working on an article about the role of capitalism in some of the current crises (rampant anxiety among the young, declining academic engagement and achievement, perhaps political disillusionment) had told me that the book had been pivotal for his early intellectual development. I can see why that might have been so. Bell's central argument - that by the 1970s, the work ethic necessary for capitalism to function was incompatible with a culture of hedonism - does not seem implausible. (Had Bell not written the book in the 1970s, but rather in the 1980s, one wonders whether he would have been equally struck by this putative incompatibility. In his 1996 afterword, Bell unfortunately doesn't address this question.) For me, though, the book was neither fish nor fowl. It didn't offer a grand enough hypothesis to make it seem like a worthy successor to the works of Schumpeter, Weber, or Durkheim. Nor did it offer enough specific evidence to seem persuasive, as somebody like Robert Putnam might have. Bell spent a lot of time discussing high culture and culture in holistic terms, rather than ordinary people's behaviors. In the end, Bell argues that our culture needs a return to the sacred, which he seems to think must come from religion. I'm not sure if that's the case.

No comments:

Post a Comment